almost 6 years agopassed
3:08

GlennCase

Source

Vocals are seriously flat right out of the gate (Specifically "world" at :04). It happens in a few other places in the song, but having it off-pitch so close to the beginning sets a bad precedent. Your vocals sound super crispy in the mix when you're hitting S sounds, and not in a good way. The other thing I am noticing is gasps of breath, with the most noticeable moments at :48 and 1:08, and 1:30. Leaving some breaths in the mix can help it sound more natural, but there is something to be said for editing some of that out, or being mindful of where you are taking breaths. It is possible to inhale without obvious gasps, and your songs will be all the better for it.
------------------------------------------
LYRICS: [OKAY] 1 point
STRUCTURE: [GOOD] 2 points
PERFORMANCE: [OKAY] 1 point
CONCEPT/CHALLENGE: [GOOD] 2 points
DYNAMICS/MIX: [OKAY] 1 point
SCORE: 7 out of 10
------------------------------------------

vowlvom

Source

like BSS, this falls into that middle ground where I don't have a huge amount to critique but the song as a whole just didn't fully grab me. One thing I did like: there's something really nice about the soft start to the first couple of verses, and the way the accordion / bass rhythm works together. One thing I didn't: a few awkward moments of lyrical rhythm, plus it sounds like you're trying to force an internal rhyme between "emotions" and "sources" that just isn't there.

glowworm

Source

inspires me to pick up the ole accordion again!

owl

Source

Your accordion playing is always impressive, and I liked the bounciness the bass added here, but this song felt super long and samey and just kind of preachy to me, and I couldn’t get into it. I think it is actually full of wisdom as far as content goes, but there’s a whole lot of telling and not a lot of showing, or wordplay, or humor--it makes it hard to go through seven steps’ worth of advice plus intro and outro.

bennyharv3

Source

Sea shanty! I don't really know what else to think other than sea shanty when I hear that cadence and accordion. Some of your vibrato and vocal runs are obviously exaggerated to fit that theme, but I think they work against you because the song is a bit long and you don't have a group chorus behind you. Having multiple voices doing their own slight variations would make the sea shanty vibe really work for you, so I think you need a couple more lines and not be consistent with where your vocal ornamentation is.

Cybronica

Source

oh! TMBG submitted a song! (I realize this can be a polarizing comment, but from me, it’s a compliment). The bass line gives me life- I’m taking notes! I like the through composed yet also strophic nature of the song, and the gradual build that it creates, that accelerates when you start shortening the steps. The shakers make a great emphasis when you bring them in. The lyrics are pretty saccharine, like the sort of cheeky goodness that captain hammer sings in dr horrible (that’s the second time I’ve referred to that in these reviews... must be on my mind). I think they don’t bother. I am a big fan of the line ‘seven is the obvious rhyme.’